But I thanked him
I’ve been puzzling over something for about a week now. Everyone has probably noticed that the US celebrated Thanksgiving last week.
On one hand, I’m annoyed that I was lied to for so long and that the myth of ‘The First Thanksgiving’ has been allowed to continue for so long. A genocide isn’t something to be celebrated really.
On the other hand, I really enjoyed having a day off with my family to cook, eat, talk, play and relax. Those are my primary memories of Thanksgiving growing up. I can also totally get on board with a day devoted to acknowledging all the good things in your life. Family, friends, health, safety, happiness, good food, warmth and many, many other things.
The thing that gave me pause? Several bloggers wrote about their Thanksgiving and specifically thankfulness to god for providing healthy children, safe homes, stable jobs, etc.
This bothered me because the implication there is that god doesn’t like/care about all his children. Those without health care, without homes, without jobs, without food, without safety are just not important or perhaps just not worthy.
I couldn’t get my head around the idea of being grateful to a god for giving ‘me’ so much while at the same time denying so much to ‘you’. I brought these thoughts to Weasel yesterday and she said she knew what this concept was: prosperity theology. Simply put, “Prosperity theology proponents promote the idea that godliness and prosperity have a causational relationship.”
I was also confused that these people seemingly took no pride in their efforts. We work hard, earn money and therefore we have food. We have access to clean water, health care and have good genes, therefore we have healthy children.
It also works on the flip side, what about amoral people who are prosperous? God favours them because… they bathe daily?
So be thankful and grateful for good things in life by all means, but don’t credit god with everything. Like the Rev. Frank Scott [Gene Hackman] in The Poseidon Adventure says, “Get down on your knees and pray to God for help and then maybe everything will work out? Garbage. Not where l come from. You could wear off your knees praying to God for heat in February. And icicles would grow from your upraised palms. If you’re freezing, you burn the furniture – but you get off your knees.”








