Kate Harding wrote about Charles Murray’s book Coming Apart: The State of White America. There is a series of questions to establish how thick one’s privilege bubble is in chapter four and she shared them. I found them so interesting, read her post first please, then read my responses and please at least think of your own responses.
It is worth reminding readers that I was born and lived in the US until I was 18 and have been in the UK ever since.
1. Have you ever lived for at least a year in a city with a population greater than 1 million?
No. I grew up in a rural town of just below 50,000 people. I now live in a small city with approximately 130,000 people, the population fluctuates because we have a large student population.
2. Have you ever lived without a car for longer than a year?
Yes. I haven’t driven a car since 1997 [one too many accidents meant I couldn't afford insurance]. When I moved to the UK in 99 there just wasn’t need for one. I’m not a fan of cars so I’m grateful I don’t need one.
3. Have you ever lived for at least a year in a municipal area in which more than 10 percent of the population was not white?
Yes. My city is ‘only’ 74% white. Growing up the racial diversity didn’t exist. I literally knew five non-white people. I’m delighted that I have access to the internet, I love reading about lives that are different from mine, so that obviously includes people of different races. I’ll never truly understand, but I want to be the best ally I can be.
4. Have you ever had a close friend of a different race?
No. I hadn’t even realised this until now. If it was just friends – not close friend – then I’d be a yes. I don’t make friends easily.
5. Have you ever had a close friend who is openly atheist?
Yes and I am myself.
6. Have you ever been to a gay wedding?
Yes, my own!
7. Are any of your close friends gay couples with children?
I don’t have any close friends with children. The only children in my life come from my sister and Weasel’s extended family and they’re all straight.
8. Do you or any of your close friends have more than $50,000 in student loan debt?
Yes. Not me, but I know several friends who have had to deal with student debt.
9. To your knowledge, have you ever met a transgendered person?
Yes. Several.
10. During the last year, have you attended a free public lecture, reading, performance, or movie screening in your community?
Yes. When the libraries were threatened with closure I went to a meeting. I should probably get more involved, but I dislike going out at night.
11. Would you and, if applicable, your partner and/or children be able to attend a different free public festival every weekend between Memorial Day and Labor Day, without traveling more than fifteen miles from home?
No. If it was 100 miles I’d be golden, London is sure to have something going on.
12. Have you or, if applicable, your partner and/or children ever been to a Planned Parenthood or similar non-profit clinic for affordable contraception, preventative health care, and/or STI testing?
No. I wasn’t that sexually active when I lived in the US. In the UK I enjoy state funded health care.
13. Have there been one or more homicides in your neighborhood in the last month?
No. Worst crime we deal with locally is drugs.
14. Have you lived for at least a year in a community with a visible homeless population?
Yes.
15. Do you have a YMCA or YWCA within five miles of your home?
Yes.
16. If, as an adult, you wanted to play a sport, take a dance class, or learn or a foreign language, would you be able to in your community? Would you have more than one option?
Yes and yes. I’ve taken Japanese, yoga, sign language and pattern making at four different facilities. There are loads more available too.
17. In the past five years, have you seen homeless people fishing in your neighborhood?
No.
18. Have you ever patronized a fast food drive-thru that had a revolving window of bullet-proof glass?
No. See question 2: no car. Additionally, drive-thrus are not common in Europe, I only know of one in my city.
19. Do you live within five miles of a mosque?
I’m not sure. I think I do. I asked Google, I totally do!
20. In the last year, have there been one or more newsworthy acts of violence at your local public high school?
No, or at least none I remember/heard about. There may have been violent acts that were hushed up or deemed petty.
21. Is there a public playground within easy walking distance of your home?
Yes. It’s about 15 minutes walk. There’s another one 30 minutes walk away.
22. Can you travel a mile from your home on foot or by wheelchair or mobility scooter without running out of sidewalk?
Yes and I do all of those modes of transport regularly.
23. Can you get from your home to a public library without using a car or spending more than $3? (How about an art museum? A sporting event? A beach? A fireworks display?)
Yes. I can walk there in 20, cycle in 10, scooter in 30 minutes. Art museum might be doable. I’d have to plan carefully. No idea of sporting events, not my cup of tea. No to the beach, but yes to bodies of water and nature. Yes to fireworks display.
24. Choose one. Who was Jane Addams? Or: Have you ever bought a tamale from a man who came by your local bar at 1 a.m.?
I don’t know who Jane Addams was and I’ve never bought a tamale from anyone.
25. Does your state receive fewer tax dollars than it contributes?
No. My county is woefully underfunded from government resources.
Isn’t it amazing how much privilege can come just from living in the ‘right’ place?